My next gun is a .357 Magnum

KeystoneTrail2

New member
Joined
Sep 10, 2025
Messages
2
After borrowing my friend's revolver for a range day, I'm torn on my next gun. A .357 Magnum feels so classic and reliable, but a 9mm semi-auto's extra rounds are tempting.
I like the idea of keeping things simple for carry. Last range trip, the revolver's kick surprised me. Which do you prefer and why?
 
Each has their own advantages and their disadvantages. It all depends on what you want to do with them, and each has their own niche to fill.

9mm is a good choice for personal defense, due, as you say, to the extra rounds. Most people seem to now be choosing the semi-autos for just that fact. Standard loadings are 115 , 124, and 147 grains.

The 357 shines in its ability to handle bullets heavier than that which is custoarily found in 9mm loadings, - the 147 gr bullet is generally the heaviest thing you will fined there, but 357's normally shoot the 158-160 gr bullet at higher velocities than a 9mm will fire a 125. 357's also handle bullet weights of 180 (and some handload even 200) grains.

You can handload very light bullets (normally 100 grains) down to very light velocities in 357 that most semiauto pistols would fire, but not function on. Revolvers do not depend on energy of the load to function reliably.

But the recoil of a full-power 357, though surprising at first, is not too difficult to live with once a person becomes accustomed to it. Barrel length is a factor there, too, as the weight of a longer barrel makes it much easier to shoot and to shoot well, something often lacking in 9mm, especially the shorter and more concealable models.

So it all comes down to what do you want to do with it - personal defense or range-toy. Remember, it all takes practice, whichever way you choose.
 
I prefer a .357 revolver like a S&W 686 for its power and simplicity. It handles .38 Special for lighter range days too. Try 158-grain JHP for carry. Good stopping power without crazy kick. What barrel length are you looking at?
 
Man, I get that struggle. I'd probably lean 9mm for carry...it has more rounds, easier recoil, and still reliable. Revolvers are classic, but for everyday simplicity and quick follow-ups, semi-autos usually win for me
 
After borrowing my friend's revolver for a range day, I'm torn on my next gun. A .357 Magnum feels so classic and reliable, but a 9mm semi-auto's extra rounds are tempting.
I like the idea of keeping things simple for carry. Last range trip, the revolver's kick surprised me. Which do you prefer and why?
Then get a little taste of BOTH .357 and increased capacity! Get a S&W Model 627 Pro! 4" or the PC "shorty"! Even if you have to buy used!
.357 with 8 round capacity and moonclip goodness!
 
After borrowing my friend's revolver for a range day, I'm torn on my next gun. A .357 Magnum feels so classic and reliable, but a 9mm semi-auto's extra rounds are tempting.
I like the idea of keeping things simple for carry. Last range trip, the revolver's kick surprised me. Which do you prefer and why?
.357 feels like character and authority, 9mm feels like practicality and capacity winning the argument.
 
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change.
Back in the old days, the 9mm was referred to as a minor caliber suitable for conscientious objectors and passivists....
 
After borrowing my friend's revolver for a range day, I'm torn on my next gun. A .357 Magnum feels so classic and reliable, but a 9mm semi-auto's extra rounds are tempting.
I like the idea of keeping things simple for carry. Last range trip, the revolver's kick surprised me. Which do you prefer and why?
I have a couple "flavors" of 9mm semi-auto and also a .357, specifically a S&W Model 627 8 shot moonclip fed! But a revolver that has been growing on me is a S&W Model 986 a 7 shot moonclip fed 9mm Luger caliber.
 
I have 2 357'S. A Taurus Tracker and a Ruger GP 100.
1781388874449.webp

1781388889453.webp
 
The Missus and I have 2 Rugers. A Security Six and a Speed Six, both of the 2 3/4 inch flavor. Not much bigger than the SP101, all stainless. The weight mitigates the recoil well. They're just a little beefier than the average S&W K frame.
1000004808.webp
 
My main CCW is a Ruger EC9s, with 7+1 in 9mm. Often I will carry one of the J-frame sized revolvers in my front jeans pocket. My favorite being the Ruger LCR in .32H&R mag. It’s self defense, not all out war! I have this cool little 8-shot .22 magnum that will blast one of three knees out of an assailant, too.
 
Keystone, I would lean towards the .357 Magnum. You don’t need to carry full house 357s, you can use .38 special cartridges for any two-legged scum that you may encounter that may have bad intentions. The Ruger SP101 with the 2 1/4” barrel is a fine gun. Many will bob the hammer for easier concealment. It’ll run as long as you want on 357s.
Smith and Wesson has some nice hammerless lightweight revolvers.
Yes, I would suggest a.357 magnum. It will pretty much take down any mammal one may encounter.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_1645.webp
    IMG_1645.webp
    526.7 KB

Latest posts

Back
Top